Five Star Roofing — Roofer in Bronx, NY
Named in 2 of 4 checks
One of 7 roofers named in New York
On the Most Recommended Roofers in New York board · July 2026 edition
AI's answer moves between checks, so we publish how many of the 4 checks named each one instead of a rank that would change if we asked again.
Five Star Roofing is one of the companies AI recommends in New York: named in 2 of the 4 checks in July 2026, on the Most Recommended Roofers board for New York.
We benchmarked 56 New York-area roofers in that run. 7 of them were ever named; the other 49 never came up at all.
It shares its group with Premier Roofing Co. and Prime One Roofing LLC; nothing in the measurement separates them. The highest count in New York was 3 of 4, reached by J. Broni Roofing Inc., Manhattan Roofing and NY Roofing and 1 more. 79 Google reviews -- 2nd of 5 here by volume, where the most-reviewed name has 159. 11% of the metro's recorded mentions landed here — 2 of 18, where the average name got 2.6.
On file for Five Star Roofing
- Operates from Bronx, NY and serves the New York market.
- Google rating at the time of the benchmark: 4.7 out of 5 across 79 reviews.
- Named in 2 of 4 checks.
- We publish how many checks named each company, not a number one -- companies named in only one check are held back, because a single mention does not repeat.
- Benchmark edition: July 2026. Results are measured, never sold.
Side by side with Five Star Roofing
The New York names that came up in the most checks, with Five Star Roofing among them.
| Named in | Roofer | Google rating | Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 of 4 | J. Broni Roofing Inc. | 5.0★ | 6 |
| 3 of 4 | Manhattan Roofing | 4.8★ | 56 |
| 3 of 4 | NY Roofing | 4.9★ | 159 |
| 2 of 4 | Five Star Roofing | 4.7★ | 79 |
The board is mention count. The rating columns are Google's, for context only.
What we asked to find Five Star Roofing
4 checks, no leading questions. A sample of what we asked:
- “I need my roof replaced in New York, New York. Which roofing company should I call?”
See every company named in New York or how the boards are measured.
Also named in New York
- 2 of 4 Premier Roofing Co.
- 2 of 4 Prime One Roofing LLC
- 3 of 4 J. Broni Roofing Inc.
- 3 of 4 Manhattan Roofing
This is Five Star Roofing's listing. Claiming it costs nothing.
The badge is free for every company on the measured list — it carries the edition date and links back to this page, so it stays honest as the counts move.
Claim Five Star Roofing's free badgeNot on the New York board?
Invisible to AI means invisible to New York homeowners. Find out where you stand, free.
See if AI recommends youBefore you call Five Star Roofing
How is the order on the New York board decided?
One input only -- how often AI named it. Here that was 2 of 4. Ask again and the order inside a group can change, which is exactly why we do not publish one.
Can Five Star Roofing pay to be listed higher?
It cannot. Placement is measured; money buys nothing here.
Does AI recommend Five Star Roofing?
AI named it in 2 of 4 New York checks that edition.
What is Five Star Roofing's Google rating?
4.7 stars, 79 reviews as recorded in July 2026.
Back to the New York board · Every named company we list · Methodology