Most RecommendedRoofers

The Most Recommended Roofers in New York — Measured on ChatGPT

ChatGPT is becoming the first stop for New York homeowners choosing a roofer. To find out who it actually sends people to, we ran 4 checks in July 2026 — 4 question styles, a cohort of 56 area companies.

The answers concentrated on a handful of names: 21 ranked in total, led by William & Hugh Roofing, which was named in 3 of the 4 checks. That leaves 35 New York-area companies ChatGPT never mentioned at all.

Next in line came NY Roofing, followed by J. Broni Roofing Inc.. 18 more companies round out the board below.

For scale: of the 34 metros in this edition, New York's cohort of 56 roofers was the 32nd largest.

Only 21 of 56

New York roofers ever appear in the answers, a 38% rate. The companies below are the ones ChatGPT names:

  1. 1

    William & Hugh Roofing

    Recommended in 3 of 4 ChatGPT checks

    Named in 3 of the 4 checks, William & Hugh Roofing holds the 1st spot on the New York board.

  2. 2

    NY Roofing

    Brooklyn, NY · Recommended in 3 of 4 ChatGPT checks · 4.9★ (159 Google reviews)

    NY Roofing earned rank 2 by showing up in 3 of the 4 checks, serving the metro from Brooklyn. Google reviewers back it up: 4.9 stars over 159 reviews.

  3. 3

    J. Broni Roofing Inc.

    Staten Island, NY · Recommended in 3 of 4 ChatGPT checks · 5.0★ (6 Google reviews)

    At #3: J. Broni Roofing Inc. of Staten Island, which came up in 3 of the 4 checks. Its Google profile shows 5.0 stars from 6 reviews.

  4. 4

    Manhattan Roofing

    New York, NY · Recommended in 3 of 4 ChatGPT checks · 4.8★ (56 Google reviews)

    Manhattan Roofing surfaced in 3 of the 4 checks when we asked. It carries a 4.8-star rating across 56 Google reviews.

  5. 5

    Five Star Roofing

    Bronx, NY · Recommended in 2 of 4 ChatGPT checks · 4.7★ (79 Google reviews)

    Spot 5 belongs to Five Star Roofing, reaching the metro from Bronx — named in 2 of the 4 checks. Google reviewers back it up: 4.7 stars over 79 reviews.

  6. 6

    Prime One Roofing LLC

    Douglaston, NY · Recommended in 2 of 4 ChatGPT checks · 5.0★ (14 Google reviews)

    Prime One Roofing LLC was recommended in 2 of the 4 checks, working out of Douglaston. Its Google profile shows 5.0 stars from 14 reviews.

  7. 7

    Premier Roofing Co.

    Recommended in 2 of 4 ChatGPT checks

    ChatGPT pointed New York homeowners to Premier Roofing Co. in 2 of the 4 checks.

  8. 8

    Goldenberg Roofing NYC

    New York, NY · Recommended in 1 of 4 ChatGPT checks · 4.9★ (118 Google reviews)

    Named in one of the 4 checks, Goldenberg Roofing NYC holds the 8th spot on the New York board. Google reviewers back it up: 4.9 stars over 118 reviews.

  9. 9

    Royal Roofing Queens

    Recommended in 1 of 4 ChatGPT checks

    Royal Roofing Queens earned rank 9 by showing up in one of the 4 checks.

  10. 10

    SAS Roofing & Waterproofing

    Brooklyn, NY · Recommended in 1 of 4 ChatGPT checks · 4.8★ (155 Google reviews)

    At #10: SAS Roofing & Waterproofing of Brooklyn, which came up in one of the 4 checks. It carries a 4.8-star rating across 155 Google reviews.

4 checks, run July 2026. This board is measured, never sold; no company can pay to be listed. Rank order follows how often ChatGPT named each one.

Every question we put to ChatGPT

We asked these word-for-word, then recorded which companies came back in the answers:

  • “Who is the best roofer in New York, New York?”
  • “I need my roof replaced in New York, New York. Which roofing company should I call?”
  • “What is the most recommended roofing company in New York, New York?”
  • “My roof is leaking — who is a trustworthy roofer near New York, New York?”

The New York measurement at a glance

  • 7 of the 21 ranked companies were named in more than one check; the rest surfaced once.
  • The ranked companies average 4.9 stars on Google, with 587 reviews between them.
  • The board reaches past New York proper — ranked companies also operate out of Brooklyn, Staten Island and Bronx.
  • Compared with the edition-wide average (27%), New York's 38% sits above the line.

Made the New York list? Claim the badge that proves it — free.

Being named is worth showing off: ranked companies get a free "Most Recommended" badge for their site, wired back to this page so the rank is checkable by anyone.

Claim your free badge

Expected to find your company on this page?

Invisible to AI means invisible to the homeowners who ask it. The free check takes about 60 seconds and shows exactly where your company stands.

See if ChatGPT recommends you

Free check by Fast Digital Marketing, the team behind this benchmark. How it works

The New York board, explained

How short is the New York list, really?

The July 2026 answer is 21. We verified 56 companies around New York and ran 4 checks; 38% of the cohort ever got a mention.

Who does ChatGPT name first in New York?

In the July 2026 measurement, William & Hugh Roofing — it came up in 3 of the 4 checks, more than any other company including NY Roofing. Frequency of naming is the entire ranking.

What questions were behind the New York checks?

Real homeowner phrasings, asked verbatim — one example: "I need my roof replaced in New York, New York. Which roofing company should I call?". Each answer's named companies were tallied, and that tally is the ranking.

Do companies pay you to be ranked here?

They can't. Measured, never sold is the standing rule: being named by ChatGPT in our checks is the only path onto the board. Money cannot buy a place on this list.

Why isn't my company on the New York list?

It means ChatGPT never named it in our July 2026 checks — nothing more. That says nothing about the quality of the work, only that homeowners who ask AI are being sent elsewhere. Most companies haven't shown up in AI answers yet.

Full methodology: how these rankings are measured. Want the bigger picture? See every U.S. metro we benchmarked.