The Most Recommended Roofers in New York — Measured on Leading AI Assistants
AI is becoming the first stop for New York homeowners choosing a roofer. To find out who it actually sends people to, we ran 4 checks in July 2026 — 4 question styles, a cohort of 56 area companies.
The answers concentrated on a handful of names: 21 in total, with J. Broni Roofing Inc., Manhattan Roofing and NY Roofing and 1 more named in 3 of 4 checks apiece. That leaves 35 New York-area companies AI never mentioned at all.
The next group is Five Star Roofing, Premier Roofing Co. and Prime One Roofing LLC — named in 2 of 4 checks.
There is no number one here on purpose. Ask AI the same question twice and the answer can change, so we publish how many of the 4 checks named each company instead of a place that would move if we asked again. Companies named in only one check aren't listed.
For scale: of the 34 metros in this edition, New York's cohort of 56 roofers was the 32nd largest.
Only 21 of 56
New York roofers ever appear in the answers, a 38% rate. The companies below are the ones AI names:
Rankings are measured and cannot be purchased — sponsored blocks are labeled advertising and sit outside the ranked list.
Ask AI the same question twice and the answer can change. So we do not crown a number one. We publish how many of the 4 checks named each company. Companies named in more checks are the ones AI keeps coming back to. Companies named in only one check are not listed: a single mention does not repeat reliably.
Named in 3 of 4 checks
4 companies, listed alphabetically — they scored the same, so nothing here puts one above another.
- 3of 4
Staten Island, NY · Recommended in 3 of 4 AI checks · 5.0★ (6 Google reviews)
J. Broni Roofing Inc. surfaced in 3 of the 4 checks when we asked; it operates from Staten Island. Its Google profile shows 5.0 stars from 6 reviews. More on J. Broni Roofing Inc. →
- 3of 4
New York, NY · Recommended in 3 of 4 AI checks · 4.8★ (56 Google reviews)
Manhattan Roofing earned its place by showing up in 3 of the 4 checks. Google reviewers back it up: 4.8 stars over 56 reviews. More on Manhattan Roofing →
- 3of 4
Brooklyn, NY · Recommended in 3 of 4 AI checks · 4.9★ (159 Google reviews)
Named in 3 of the 4 checks: NY Roofing, reaching the metro from Brooklyn. Its Google profile shows 4.9 stars from 159 reviews. More on NY Roofing →
- 3of 4
Recommended in 3 of 4 AI checks
AI pointed New York homeowners to William & Hugh Roofing in 3 of the 4 checks. More on William & Hugh Roofing →
Named in 2 of 4 checks
3 companies, listed alphabetically — they scored the same, so nothing here puts one above another.
- 2of 4
Bronx, NY · Recommended in 2 of 4 AI checks · 4.7★ (79 Google reviews)
Five Star Roofing surfaced in 2 of the 4 checks when we asked; it operates from Bronx. It carries a 4.7-star rating across 79 Google reviews. More on Five Star Roofing →
- 2of 4
Recommended in 2 of 4 AI checks
Premier Roofing Co. earned its place by showing up in 2 of the 4 checks. More on Premier Roofing Co. →
- 2of 4
Douglaston, NY · Recommended in 2 of 4 AI checks · 5.0★ (14 Google reviews)
Prime One Roofing LLC of Douglaston came up in 2 of the 4 checks. Its Google profile shows 5.0 stars from 14 reviews. More on Prime One Roofing LLC →
3 more companies were named in exactly one of the 4 checks. A single mention comes back less than half the time when we ask again, so they are measured but not published.
4 checks, run July 2026. This board is measured, never sold; no company can pay to be listed. Grouping follows how often AI named each one, and names inside a group are alphabetical.
Every company above has its own page showing how it was measured. Browse all companies we measure.
Every question we put to AI
We asked these word-for-word, then recorded which companies came back in the answers:
- “Who is the best roofer in New York, New York?”
- “I need my roof replaced in New York, New York. Which roofing company should I call?”
- “What is the most recommended roofing company in New York, New York?”
- “My roof is leaking — who is a trustworthy roofer near New York, New York?”
The New York measurement at a glance
- 7 of the 21 companies AI named came up in more than one check. The other 3 surfaced once and aren't listed — a single mention doesn't hold up on a re-ask.
- The listed companies average 4.9 stars on Google, with 314 reviews between them.
- The board reaches past New York proper — listed companies also operate out of Staten Island, Brooklyn and Bronx.
- Compared with the edition-wide average (27%), New York's 38% sits above the line.
Made the New York list? Claim the badge that proves it — free.
Being named is worth showing off: listed companies get a free "Most Recommended" badge for their site, wired back to this page so the count behind it is checkable by anyone.
Claim your free badgeExpected to find your company on this page?
Invisible to AI means invisible to the homeowners who ask it. The free check takes about 60 seconds and shows exactly where your company stands.
See if AI recommends youFree check by Fast Digital Marketing, the team behind this benchmark. How it works
The New York board, explained
How short is the New York list, really?
The July 2026 answer is 21. We verified 56 companies around New York and ran 4 checks; 38% of the cohort ever got a mention.
Who does AI name most often in New York?
No single answer. J. Broni Roofing Inc., Manhattan Roofing and NY Roofing and 1 more each came up in 3 of the 4 checks, which is as far as 4 checks can tell them apart.
How is the order on this page decided?
Because a number one wouldn't hold. Ask AI the same question again and the top name often changes, while the number of checks that named a company stays about the same. So we publish the count: companies named in the same number of the 4 checks are grouped together and listed alphabetically, because nothing in the measurement separates them.
What questions were behind the New York checks?
Real homeowner phrasings, asked verbatim — one example: "I need my roof replaced in New York, New York. Which roofing company should I call?". Each answer's named companies were tallied, and that tally is the whole list.
Do companies pay you to be listed here?
They can't. Measured, never sold is the standing rule: being named by AI in our checks is the only path onto the board. Sponsored blocks are marked as advertising and never enter the measured list.
Why isn't my company on the New York list?
Either AI never named it in our July 2026 checks, or it came up in only one of them — and one mention isn't steady enough to publish. Neither says anything about the quality of the work, only that homeowners who ask AI are being sent elsewhere.
New to New York? These roofers are just getting started.
Everything above this line was measured. The list on this page comes from asking AI assistants real questions and counting who they named — no one can buy their way onto it.
This section is different, and we want to be plain about it. The businesses below are brand new. They have not been measured, they have no rank and no score, and they are not part of the list above. They are here because they asked to be, we checked that they are real, and a business that opened last month has no way to show up in a ranking built on history. Nobody paid for a spot here — it is free, and it is not an endorsement.
Just opened a company in New York? You can be the first one here.
Tell us who you are and we'll add you to this section — free. It is not a ranking and it will never say you are ranked, because you are not: you are new. When we re-run the benchmark, a real spot on the list above is something you earn, not something we hand out.
Add your new businessFull methodology: how these rankings are measured. Want the bigger picture? See every U.S. metro we benchmarked.